Advertised rates are still falling, down 1.8% nationally in September, and a smaller construction pipeline hasn't lifted them yet. If your revenue slides like that next year, can your loan take it?
On a typical 50,000 NRSF facility, a 10% revenue drop still covers the note and a 20% drop doesn't. Those are the two cases Argus Self-Storage Advisors tells owners to test. The math is below, plus the four other questions that decide whether you hold.
What happened
Modern Storage Media's November market read pulls together Yardi's rate data and advice from brokers on who should hold. We covered the rate numbers when Yardi released them, in our earlier post on the rate drop, so here's what's new.
Ben Vestal, CEO of Argus Self-Storage Advisors, lays out a hold test. Owners should be ready to keep the property at least five years and have financing locked for a contractual three to five years. They should also have enough cash to pay debt service if revenue falls 10% to 20%, per the article.
Two more questions are about position. Is your facility one of the five most competitive in its three-mile submarket, and can that submarket take one more competitor? Vestal's rule:
"If you answered 'no' to more than one of the questions, you consider selling and moving on from the self-storage sector." (Ben Vestal, Argus, Modern Storage Media)
Competitors are under strain too. Nicholas Malagisi of Storage Realty Advisors says the biggest REITs slid from roughly 94% to 96% occupancy to 88% to 90%, and answered with steep promotions, the article reports. Some operators are now pulling those promotions back, and larger ones are posting NOI growth again.
SmartStop's third quarter shows that pattern. Same-store NOI rose 4.9% on 2% more revenue and 3.8% lower operating expenses, while average physical occupancy slipped 0.4 points to 92.2%. It also plans $75 million to $125 million of sales starting in early 2027, aimed at markets where it runs one or a few facilities, because those can't share staffing, marketing and revenue management.
Money is still moving. Buyers are active and well funded, Vestal says, but they'll only pay for assets priced to today's market. The Self-Storage Association's survey taken after the Sept. 16 rate hike found 63% of respondents expect conditions a year out to be the same or better.
What it means for your facility
Here's the stress test on numbers you can swap for your own. These are our assumptions, not Argus's: 50,000 NRSF, 90% economic occupancy, $1.20 a foot a month, operating expenses at 35% of revenue and held flat, and $300,000 a year in debt service.
- Revenue: $648,000 a year
- Operating expenses: $226,800
- NOI: $421,200
- Coverage: 1.40 times debt service, with $121,200 left over
Now cut revenue and leave expenses where they are.
| Revenue drop | Revenue | NOI | Coverage | Cash after debt service |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| None | $648,000 | $421,200 | 1.40 | $121,200 |
| 10% | $583,200 | $356,400 | 1.19 | $56,400 |
| 20% | $518,400 | $291,600 | 0.97 | -$8,400 |

This facility passes the 10% test and fails the 20% one. Its cushion runs out at an 18.7% revenue drop, which is $526,800 a year. Below that, you're paying the lender out of your pocket.
Two cautions. Real expenses flex a little when revenue falls, so your line may look kinder. Your own debt service could also be far from $300,000, and that's the number that moves the answer most.
The same NOI also moves in value. Vestal puts cap rates at 5.75% to 8.5%, depending on market and location. On $421,200 of NOI, that's $7.33M at 5.75%, $6.02M at 7% and $4.96M at 8.5%. The gap between the ends is $2.37 million, from the cap rate alone.

That's why the broker's advice to price realistically matters. A seller who anchors to the 5.75% number in a 7% market sits on the shelf while buyers move on.
Here's how we read it. The position test is the one you can still change. You can't rewrite your loan this month, but you can improve where you rank in your submarket. Rate, reviews and Map Pack position are the levers. Our REIT benchmark shows the expense side of the same story, and SmartStop's expansion plans show where a large operator wants its stores.
What to check this week
- Pull last year's NOI and your annual debt service. Divide one by the other. Then repeat it with revenue down 10% and 20% and expenses unchanged.
- Write down your loan maturity, rate type and lender. A quarter-point hike on Sept. 16, with another possible by year-end, puts any loan coming due at the top of the list.
- Rank yourself against the competitors within three miles on advertised 10x10 street rate, review count and where each GBP shows in the Map Pack for "storage units near me."
- Count your "no" answers to the five Argus questions: five-year hold, three-to-five-year financing, the 20% test, top-five position, room for another competitor.
- If you answered "no" twice or more, ask a broker for a value range at 5.75%, 7% and 8.5% before you decide anything.
If your rank in the submarket is the weak spot, that's the work our self-storage marketing service does, and our GBP service covers the Map Pack piece.
