Public Storage pushed new-tenant rates up 9.3% over the year, and the other three big REITs went the opposite way and cut to chase volume, according to TractIQ. The summary doesn't say which bet filled more units.
So don't copy either one on faith. Price it. On our math below, a 9.3% increase on move-ins still pays if you lose fewer than about 8.5% of them.
What happened
TractIQ's Q3 2026 report covers Extra Space, Public Storage, CubeSmart and SmartStop. We've read the summary on Modern Storage Media, not the full report, which sits behind a download. Several figures below carry no stated quarter, so treat them as TractIQ's headline read.
TractIQ says this is the first quarter since it began tracking storage in 2024 when all four posted yearly gains in same-store revenue, NOI and achieved rent. All four also lifted full-year guidance again.
The rest of the headline numbers from TractIQ:
- Sector occupancy averages 91.7%, weighted, up from 2024 and 2025. TractIQ thinks 2025 was probably the bottom.
- Achieved rent is $21.56 per occupied square foot, up 1.2%.
- REITs run roughly 8 points of occupancy above non-REIT operators.
- Extra Space and CubeSmart put 8x more money into buybacks than into stores.
- The REIT development pipeline is 184 facilities and 11.1 million square feet.
TractIQ's own read is that this looks more like relief from new supply than a jump in demand. That matters for rates. If demand isn't carrying the recovery, a price increase has to hold on its own.
A non-REIT manager reported the same direction for the same quarter. Storage Asset Management said same-store revenue rose 2.5% and NOI rose 1.1% against Q3 2025. Over nine months, the figures were 2.6% and 2.2%.

What it means for your facility
The rate bet. Assume your facility rents 20 10x10s a month at a $120 street rate. That's $2,400 of new monthly rent. These are our assumptions, not TractIQ's.
Raise move-in rates 9.3% and the street rate goes to $131.16. Each move-in pays $11.16 more a month. You'd need only 18.30 move-ins to bring in the same $2,400, so you can lose 1.70 of the 20. That's 8.51%.
If the higher rate costs you more than that, you're collecting less. It also leaves units empty, and an empty unit pays nothing until someone rents it. Our post on rate cuts and move-ins runs the same arithmetic in the other direction.
The occupancy gap. Assume a 50,000 NRSF store renting at $1.50 a foot a month. Eight points of occupancy is 4,000 NRSF. At $1.50 that's $6,000 a month, or $72,000 a year. TractIQ says the gap is roughly 8 points, so read that as the size of the prize, not your number.
The cost line. SAM's NOI grew slower than its revenue in both periods. That means costs grew faster than revenue. SAM doesn't publish its expenses, so we've assumed a 35% expense ratio on $750,000 of revenue. That's $262,500 of expenses and $487,500 of NOI.
Apply SAM's Q3 growth rates: revenue at 2.5% growth is $768,750. NOI at 1.1% growth is $492,862.50. The difference is $275,887.50 of expenses, up 5.10%. Expenses grew about twice as fast as revenue. Our Extra Space comparison shows a REIT whose costs fell in the same quarter.
Our read as operators: a rate increase is the cheapest NOI only if your lead flow can take it. If calls and web reservations are flat, a 9.3% move trades volume for rate in a market TractIQ calls supply relief.
What to check this week
- Pull your move-ins and street rate by unit class for the last 90 days. Divide the move-in count by three.
- For one class, divide your monthly new rent by the street rate after a 9.3% increase. The gap from today's count is the move-ins you can afford to lose.
- Compare your street rates with the three closest competitors. If most of them cut, a big increase puts you above the market for shoppers.
- Check your occupancy against TractIQ's 91.7% only if your pool is comparable. SAM counts a store as stabilized after three years open, or after a calendar year at 80% or more average occupancy.
- Split your Q3 NOI change into revenue and expenses. If expenses rose faster than revenue, fix that before you touch rates.
If you want move-ins, calls and rates read together each month, that's our self-storage marketing service.

