All articles

Fishkill Storage Denial Upheld: Budget for Review Fees

A NY court backed a town that denied a 333-unit storage project and kept its consulting fees. Here's what to carry in a development budget and check this week.

By SD Marketing Team4 min readNewsStrategy
A grid of storage units wired to a card reading 85% assumed occupancy, where $155,000 in review fees equals 4.06 months of rent, and a search for storage near me.

If you're planning ground-up storage, budget for more than the environmental review fee cap, and don't count on a court to rescue a denial. A New York court just sided with a town on both.

The developer is appealing, so this isn't settled. But the trial-level result is a useful read on zoning risk and fee exposure.

What happened

A developer, 1292 Realty LLC, wanted to build a two-story, 333-unit storage facility at 1292 Route 9D in Fishkill, New York. The parcel is 4.7 acres near I-84, and the plans first went in during 2022, per Modern Storage Media.

The site sat in a restricted business zone, where storage needs special approval. After three years of reviews, studies and hearings, the Planning Board voted unanimously to deny it in October 2025.

The developer sued. It argued that storage would disrupt the area less than hotels, restaurants or offices, which the zone allows. It also challenged about $155,000 in review fees, saying the town went past what state environmental review law allows, the same report says.

State Supreme Court Justice Michael Hayes dismissed both claims in an Oct. 8 ruling. He found the board had a rational basis, citing the town's comprehensive plan, neighborhood impacts and the worry that storage could deaden a commercial corridor. On fees, the developer said the environmental review charge should top out near $11,000. The judge said state law lets a town recover reasonable consulting costs beyond the environmental impact statement work, per the report.

1292 Realty filed its appeal on Oct. 26.

What it means for your facility

Two lessons, one about the denial and one about the fees.

On the denial, a board only needs a rational basis. Here it had three, and a court accepted them. Arguing that storage is quieter than a hotel didn't move the judge. If your site needs special approval, the question to answer early is how the use fits the town's comprehensive plan, not how it compares with other uses.

On the fees, the report doesn't say how the $155,000 splits between environmental review and outside consultants. So treat these numbers as a scale check, not a forecast. If a town billed that much on a project this size:

Here's what that does to a pro forma. Assume 333 units at a $135 average street rate and 85% occupancy. Those are our assumptions, so use yours. Rent comes to 333 × $135 × 85% = $38,212.50 a month. Fees of $155,000 equal 4.06 months of that rent, before a single move-in. A budget built on the statutory figure is short by roughly four months of stabilized income.

Timing matters as much. This project spent three years in review. Every month of that is land carry, so a denial costs you the fees and the delay.

Approvals can stall on small items too. The same week, U-Haul said a permanent propane tank at its Branson store ran into approval trouble. The store went with an off-grid skid system instead. That's one store and a company announcement, so treat its cost and performance claims as unproven. The takeaway is narrower: ask what an add-on needs before you commit to a design.

What to check this week

  1. Pull the zoning for every site you're underwriting. Mark each where storage needs special approval or a variance.
  2. For those sites, read the comprehensive plan language on commercial corridors and neighborhood character. Write one paragraph on how your use fits it.
  3. Ask the town for its fee schedule and its policy on outside consultants. Ask whether applicants are billed for actual consultant time.
  4. Add a review-fee line to each pro forma beyond the statutory figure. Test it at several times the cap and see if the deal still works.
  5. Add the months of review to your carry costs. If the town took three years here, would your site still pencil?
  6. For ancillary services like propane or EV charging, confirm the approval path before you order equipment.

For more on local costs and supply in your trade area, see our posts on supply pipeline by trade area and local permit fees. Once a site clears approvals, our self-storage marketing work gets the lease-up moving.

Sources

About SD Marketing

We're storage operators first, marketers second. Everything we recommend is tested on our own facilities before we suggest it to clients. Want to discuss how these strategies apply to your facility?

Schedule a Free Consultation